Should I get an Extended Car Warranty

How to decide if an extended car warranty is right or you?

Extended car warranties are not for everyone, but they can make sense in certain situations. Use the decision tree below to help you determine whether or not you should consider an extended car warranty.

Infographic on how to get a car warranty

When to consider a warranty and when to pass

Consider an extended warranty if…

  • Your particular model has a reputation for problems
  • You cannot live with surprise repair bills
  • You will read the contract fully

Don't get an extended warranty if…

  • You can afford a $600 repair bill
  • Your model is covered by a warranty now*
  • You can’t afford the full coverage you need
  • Your car is worth less than $1,500

* If you own a vehicle that still has some of the manufacturer’s warranty left, particularly the initial, “comprehensive” warranty, you are in a good position. Most manufacturers will sell you an extended warranty direct from them, but only before your new-car warranty expires. If you are already thinking you might want one, get moving before the original warranty runs out. It offers you options you won’t have later. However, before you do, make certain you know what your full warranty coverage is for the vehicle you own. Hyundai, for example, covers its initial owners for up to 100,000 miles or ten years. Don’t buy what you already own.

Recommended extended warranty providers

Endurance

Endurance is an extended car warranty provider that sells and administers its own policies. The company that has a strong presence in the market and has earned good reviews.You can read our full review of Endurance here.

CARCHEX

CARCHEX is a flexible car warranty company, offering drivers a wide range of plan options. In contrast to warranty providers with shady reputations, CARCHEX has earned an A+ rating from BBB. You can read our full review of CARCHEXreview here.

Chrysler Warranty Direct

Those drivers who own a vehicle made by FCA (Chrysler, Dodge, RAM, Jeep, Alfa Romeo, Fiat) should start their search for an extended warranty at the Chrysler Warranty Direct program. There are a few things Car Talks likes about CWD. They’re a direct provider, meaning they don’t turn you over to a third party when trouble happens. Chrysler Warranty Direct also uses your brand’s original parts to service your vehicle. Finally, all of the work performed is by authorized FCA dealerships with technicians trained by the manufacturer.

GM Extended Protection Plan

GM Extended Protection Plans cover General Motors vehicles (Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, and Cadillac) and can extend the coverage of your bumper-to-bumper warranty for up to 10 years. The plans are sold through authorized resellers and GM’s dealerships, but GM administers this program. Simplicity is one benefit of a GM Extended Protection Plan. You don’t need paperwork or a membership card. Any authorized GM dealer can access your plan information from the car’s VIN and will provide repairs using GM-trained technicians, and service your vehicle with GM parts.

What is an extended car warranty?

An extended warranty for your car, truck, crossover, SUV, or motorcycle is extra protection from unplanned repairs and breakdowns. It takes over after the manufacturer’s warranty ends. Don’t confuse an extended warranty with a pre-paid maintenance plan.They are two separate things. So you will still be paying for oil changes, timing belt service, spark plugs, transmission fluid service, tires, battery replacement and that sort of routine, scheduled work out of pocket. An extended warranty only helps you when something unexpected happens to a system you bought coverage for. For example, if your alternator quits.

Extended warranties can be offered from the manufacturer who built your vehicle, they can be direct from a third party, and often they are from a company that sells you a plan and then sets you up with another provider to cover the claims. They are not all equal.

You can purchase an extended warranty that will cover nearly every possible repair needed. Conversely, you can buy a less expensive plan that only covers some of the bigger and more expensive problems that might arise. Many of the disappointed customers who post angy-grams in reviews purchased a warranty that didn’t cover what then broke on their vehicle. When they try to use the extended warranty, they are horrified to find out that the contract, which they didn’t read, plainly states that the item is not covered. So above all else, read and understand the contract you are offered to ensure you know exactly what you are getting, and what you are not.

Pros & Cons of extended warranties

  • Offers vehicle owners a fixed cost of ownership.
  • Can eliminate surprise repair bills that bust a budget.
  • Great for cars you love but that have a bad reputation for quality.
  • Can often be transferred or cancelled with money back if you sell the vehicle.
  • Most people pay more for the warranty than they get back in repairs.
  • May not cover your repair if you have not purchased full coverage.
  • Some shady operators among those selling plans.
  • Deductibles, waiting periods and vehicle inspections often apply.

When should you consider an extended car warranty?

Certain vehicles are well known to have major repair needs. We pick on Land Rover sometimes, but let’s choose among some of the more common everyday cars we all drive. Subaru has a reputation for large issues with the engines in the ten-year old generation. They can have head gasket issues that lead to overheating. Nissan was a pioneer in CVT transmissions and the earlier vehicles have a reputation for trouble with that component. There are even a few years of the bullet-proof Prius that struggled with headlight issues. If the vehicle you drive has a known track record of trouble, a warranty may make sense.

Some of us live on a budget that runs week to week or month to month. If you can’t afford a surprise breakdown with a four-figure repair bill, an extended warranty might be right for you. Just keep in mind that according to Consumer Reports studies, most people pay out for a warranty more than they recoup in covered repair bills.

Others among us just hate surprises. If you own a highly reliable but older vehicle, a warranty may still be worth the cost. Let’s say you have a 2010 Lexus IS 350C with a retractable hardtop roof. If that roof runs into any trouble your extended warranty is going to pay for itself in one repair. Wouldn’t it be a nice feeling to have a fixed cost of ownership and keep driving the car you love?

When to say “no” to an extended warranty?

If a robot caller or a happy lady recording just buzzed your cell and offered you a warranty, we suggest declining the offer and stepping back. Do your research. Don’t buy a warranty as a result of a cheesy sales pitch. Many of the best warranty companies, CARCHEX, for example, do not offer unsolicited sales pitches.

As we have highlighted above, extended car warranties are not for everyone. Most of all, those who own a new or used car already covered by a warranty. New cars have warranties as long as 100,000 miles, but they typically have two milestones. The first is the comprehensive warranty that runs to three years of 36K miles. The drivetrain warranty then continues on to five years or 60K miles. Certified pre-owned vehicles come with warranties that usually last at least one full year and 10,000 miles. You may not need coverage, but you could bookmark your calendar for a few months before the warranty expires for reconsideration.

You also don’t need an extended car warranty if you can afford to fix a typical large repair yourself, or replace an old vehicle when its useful life has ended. The typical large repair is about $600. If you can manage that once or twice per year, save your money on an extended warranty. Finally, if your vehicle has a value of less than $1,500, do you really want to purchase an extended warranty that will cost you more than the vehicle’s value?

One last note: If you already have a car in need of a costly repair and hope to sign up, get the car fixed, and then cancel the plan, think again. These companies are experts at detecting fraud, and they are smart enough to make you wait a few months before coverage begins. Some even inspect your vehicle prior to approval.

How to get the best deal on an extended warranty?

Shop around. You can shop for an extended warranty by phone. We have done it ourselves and discovered that the prices for warranties that manufacturers like Lexus offer are not set in stone. In ten minutes of phoning a few dealers we found that the same warranty can vary by hundreds of dollars from one dealership to the next.

If you are buying a used car and the dealer is offering you a warranty, get the price in writing and then go home and do some research. How highly is the company that is administering the warranty rated? Price is just one aspect of value. A low price is worthless if the last 20 Google reviews all said that the company ignored the vehicle owners’ claims. (Which is exactly what we found when we researched one warranty company this very week).

If the company that you have been offered a quote from is reliable, shop the price around a bit. Call the company directly and see if they will sell you the same policy for less. Call other highly-rated warranty companies and see if they have a similar plan for less money. It doesn't take you long to get a few comparable quotes, and you can see reviews at three places instantly; Google Reviews, Yelp, and Better Business Bureau. And of course within this very Car Talk story!

FAQ

How much do extended warranties cost?

Extended car warranties vary in price from a low of $500 to more than $3,000. Monthly payments are typically between about $75 and $125. Many variables impact the cost.

Can I negotiate prices on an extended car warranty?

You can negotiate anything, including an extended car warranty. Shop around and carefully consider the coverage you wish to purchase.

What do extended warranties cover?

Extended warranties can be comprehensive, or “bumper to bumper” or they can cover just specific parts and systems. You get what you pay for. Note that extended warranties do not cover normal maintenance or wear items like batteries, tires, timing belts, and oil changes.

Why should you get an extended warranty?

Extended warranties work for people that can't afford a surprise bill that will upset their budget. They are also a wise purchase for vehicles that have a history of needing pricey repairs.

Why shouldn't you get an extended warranty?

Most people who buy extended warranties pay more for the warranty then they recoup in covered repairs. Also, if you already have warranty coverage, or if you can afford and stomach a large repair bill you should think carefully before buying.

Compare Prices

The best way to get a good price is to compare offers. We recommend reaching out to...

Carchex Logo
Most variety in plan options
Get Quote
Endurance Logo
Best direct service provider
Get Quote